• Home
  • News
  • Doctor Who Reviews
  • In the Press
  • Contact
theregenerationstheregenerations
  • Home
  • News
  • Doctor Who Reviews
  • In the Press
  • Contact

Goodbye Peter Capaldi, hello female Doctor?

The Doctor and Missy

Goodbye Peter Capaldi, hello female Doctor?

January 31, 2017 News

Yesterday, January 30th 2017, during Jo Whiley’s show on BBC Radio 2, the Twelfth Doctor – Peter Capaldi – announced that he felt ‘it was time to move on’and he would leave the role at the end of the year. Speculation was rife about his successor – just who would be the 13th Doctor? As show runner and guiding hand of the series, Steven Moffat had been keen on injecting gender politics throughout his tenure. References to more women being in charge in the future had the Doctor commenting, ‘We can only hope’. A female Time Lord remarks that following her latest regeneration it’s good to being a female again and ‘back to normal’. Companions including Amy Pond and Clara Oswald frequently made anti-man jokes too. So is this misandry  or just lighthearted banter, a gentle nod towards ‘redressing’ the perceived gender balance that has long had women playing the sidekick role? Or is this dialogue just as unwanted; employing degradation towards men being no better than the reverse? Sexism, Doctor Who and the reflection of the changing face of television and Western culture warrants its own article so I’ll hold fire on passing more of these comments for now.

Would it be gender-swapping?

So, the Doctor is a Time Lord, a Gallifreyan whose race’s biology has been hinted at over many years but thankfully for dramatic reasons we don’t know all that much. Do they reproduce along the same lines as us? Are they grown on ‘looms’ like Marc Platt referenced in his Virgin New Adventures novel Lungbarrow. Or something totally different? As always the mystery is likely to be more intriguing than any actual explanations. Are Time Lords ‘male’ and ‘female’ in any traditional sense except outwardly? Is gender swapping an accurate expression for such a change? I would like to think that a race as old as the Time Lords would have transcended gender identities to some degree. After all, it seems such a small issue compared to the weightier, astronomical, space-time, universal-order thoughts that the race is supposed to dwell on.

Casting a woman as the Doctor?

Jokingly (perhaps!) Tom Baker, the impressively long scarfed Fourth Doctor, in the 1970s suggested that he wished his successor well ‘whomever he or she may be’. More recently in modern Who, gender swapping as a result of regeneration was being woven into the mythos. The Neil Gaiman-scripted episode The Doctor’s Wife has a line about a Time Lord called Corsair having two female personas in the past. That was in the sixth series (2011) but it was finally in the eighth series (2014) that a gender-swapping Time Lord took centre stage. An enigmatic lady who had appeared in cameos throughout the series finally confronted the Doctor in the penultimate tale, announcing herself as the latest iteration of The Master. Missy, played astonishingly well by Michelle Gomez, soon put me at my ease. The initial rejection that I felt towards her – after all, Roger Delgado and Anthony Ainley were my Masters – changed to warmth and joyous acceptance because of the way in which Gomez convincingly played the part and with such gusto. So gender swapping Time Lords can work if they are written and acted well. Casting is all-important too.

Could it really happen?

We are getting into precarious territory here. In the 1960s it was a big jump to recast any leading man’s part and I’m not sure if we are ready for the quintessential ‘Edwardian gentleman’ time traveller to become female. Yes of course you have the argument that we have a 900+ year-old alien who can change his appearance and operate a TARDIS keeping within your suspension of disbelief but you are arguing about him being played by a woman. However, the bottom line is that we are hardwired into recognising other humans by characteristics including gender and we are also in the era of the social justice warrior (SJW) who are pushing an agenda of females trumping and belittling males. So if the reason for switching actor to actress is a publicity stunt or some misguided attempt to meet a female drama lead quota then the new series will bomb. Why? Well, because you have a predominantly male fan base who won’t take kindly to their favourite series being used as some political or satirical pawn and you aren’t likely to generate a brand new SJW audience to fill the gap. The phrase ‘Get woke, go broke’ is very fitting.

‘Change my dear…

and not a moment too soon’ were among Colin Baker’s first words as the Sixth Doctor. Gone was the young, gentle, empathetic Fifth Doctor, played by Peter Davison and here was a brash, aggressive and initially unlikable Time Lord in his place. While Baker’s nuanced character didn’t get chance to shine until his excellent Big Finish Productions outings, such a switch of personality refreshed the show. Change is good – and in my view – essential for any long-running programme. Variety, novelty and a freshening up of the format generates media buzz, attracts new watchers, and gives loyal followers and fanatics (yours truly) a reason to keep on watching the evolving show. Each regeneration of the Doctor warrants a regeneration of the series itself. Nothing can stand still forever.

Will I welcome a female Doctor?

My first instinct is to say I want the Doctor to remain male. But if the powers that be decide to reinvigorate the franchise by gender swapping the character then my hope will be for an excellent actress who can play ‘otherworldly’ and command the screen with an attitude of someone who seems much older in experience than she looks. I’m kind of excited to see if they will actually cast an actress – it could bring a new lease of life if done respectfully to the character. Prior to Michelle Gomez’ take on the Master I would have been dead set against it but now…

Whatever happens I’ll be watching and until then I’ll reserve judgement!

You also might be interested in

Who is Jodie Whittaker?

Will Jodie Whittaker be a good Doctor Who?

Jul 17, 2017

Now that the dust has settled with the BBC’s reveal[...]

Doctor Who new series 1 episode 1 Rose

Episode 1 – Rose

Oct 3, 2018

2005! Seems so long ago yet recent at the same[...]

The Macra Terror returns on Blu-ray and DVD 2019

The Macra Terror returns on Blu-ray and DVD 2019

Dec 5, 2018

The 4 x 25 min missing episodes, which were originally[...]

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search

Categories

  • Big Finish (1)
    • Eighth Doctor (1)
  • Blu-ray (2)
  • DVD (1)
  • In the Press (2)
    • Season 02 1964 (1)
  • News (10)
  • Series 1 reviews (13)
  • Series 11 reviews (9)
  • Special Effects VFX (1)
  • Specials (1)
  • VHS reviews (1)
Check out all my Doctor Who reviews Read more reviews

About me

the regenerations is my first Doctor Who fan site. I’ve loved Who since the classic era and, although I enjoy most of the modern stories, I’m critical of some and occasionally the way the series progresses.
But in my heart I remain optimistic for the future with my favourite time traveller!

 

My reviews

I enjoy reviewing stories and none more so than those of Doctor Who. To help fund my site I am an Amazon Associate and earn from qualifying purchases. However, I write honest reviews based on my opinions and I don’t receive any products from for free and quite happily say if I don’t think something is up to scratch 🙂

Latest Posts

  • The Macra Terror returns on Blu-ray and DVD 2019 The 4 x 25 min missing episodes, which were originally...
    Read More
  • Who Year’s Day! New Year – Nee Doctor Who! Turning the lack of...
    Read More
  • Tom Baker’s final season comes to blu-ray special edition Tom Baker’s final season hits the shelves as a blu-ray...
    Read More
  • Episode 9 – It Takes you Away Wow! Where to start? I had been dreading this episode,...
    Read More
  • Episode 8 – The Witchfinders Wow! Where to start? I had been dreading this episode,...
    Read More

Site and text copy is copyright © 2023 · the regenerations and may not be reproduced anywhere without permission of this site. All rights reserved.
Doctor Who, images, logos are the property of BBC. Big Finish audio artwork and logo is copyright Big Finish.. No infringement is intended and any use is under fair use for the purposes of review. If you feel I have infringed your copyright/trademarks please contact me on my contact page where I will attempt to resolve the matter. Thanks!

Next